Speech on the relationship of international law to the U.S. Supreme Court at Georgetown University

October 27, 2004

ITEM DETAILS

Type: Speech
Physical location/Show name: Georgetown University
Date is approximate: No
hotung.jpg

Transcript

Sandra Day O'Connor
Thank you Dean Atlanta so much. Thank you. Thank you. His Eminence Cardinal McCarrick, President there, joi de Dana Lana cough and Dean Emeritus Judy or bream, and faculty, students and friends of Georgetown University Law Center. This is a very happy occasion indeed. And I'm glad that as a neighbor, I was invited to come over and share this day with you.

Georgetown University Law Center is our nation's largest law school. consolidating its broad and international law programs under one roof in the new Eric EO tongue, international law building the generosity of ambassador and Mrs. How tongue has made this possible. This law school, which is located in our nation's capital, already has one of the most comprehensive international and comparative law programs in the world. It has at least 22 talented faculty members focused on these areas. Students from at least 71 countries are enrolled here in the International Programs. alumni of this law school live all across the globe. And as you've heard from the dean, the law school is already home to many many diverse programs in the international area, in short, Georgia. University Law Center is now situated to be the leading global Law Center in this country and perhaps in the world. No wonder this is a special day. International Law has emerged in ways that affect all courts here and abroad. The reason is globalization. It's important should not be underestimated. 30% or more of our gross domestic product is internationally derived.

We operate today under a very large array of international agreements, treaties, organizations, the UN Convention on contracts for the International sale of goods, NAFTA, the World Trade Organization, the Hague conventions on collection of evidence abroad and on service of process and the New York Convention on the recognition And enforcement of foreign arbitrarily awards dimension, only a very few. But globalization is much more than just these agreements and these organizations. Globalization also represents a greater awareness of an access to peoples and places far different from our own. The fates of nations are more closely intertwined than ever before. And we are more acutely aware of the connections as we learned in this country on September 11th 2001 these connections can sometimes be devastating rather than constructive. But as we are also learning in the post September 11 world, the power of international cooperation and international understanding is much greater than the obstacles we face.

The term National Law is used loosely to describe different things. It includes public international law, that is the law regulating the intercourse of nations. It also includes private international law, the laws and choice of law rules governing cross border activities of individuals, corporations, and other entities. And the study of international law deals with other activities and regulations, such as domestic statutes with extra territorial application, cross border coordination of regulatory schemes, the recognition of foreign judgments, and the treatment of aliens by our own and other countries. Finally, under our Constitution, treaties made by our country constitute part of this supreme law of our land, international law stemming from these various sources, is at least a concern for the lawyer counseling her client on issues ranging from commerce to the environment, to family law to human rights to anti immigration to intellectual property.

International Law is no longer an issue only for diplomats although some of you are present today and trade lawyers. With increasing globalization international law affects business and litigation decisions across the board. And lawyers in their role as counselors must recognize potential international law issues, even when they show up in unexpected contacts. last term by way of example, our supreme court decided six cases
presenting international law issues The cases we resolved included an interpretation of a treaty, the worst our convention on air travel and transport. We also interpreted United States statutes touching on international law issues, such as the foreign trade antitrust improvements at the federal statute authorizing discovery in Ada foreign proceedings, the foreign Sovereign Immunities act, and the Federal Tort Claims Act. Finally, parties discussed as well as the as well, the effect of international law in cases about the application of the writ of habeas corpus to detainees in Guantanamo Bay. These issues are only the tip of the iceberg of such international law issues in both federal and state courts. Most such disputes are resolved by the federal and state courts with Ever reaching the Supreme Court, and many international law disputes are resolved in proceedings with private arbitrators, mediators or various international urban trouble bodies.

This is an interesting time in world history. For one thing for the first time, there are now democratically elected governments and more than half the countries of the world, approximately 120 by last count out of 190 nation states, even in countries which do not have democratically elected governments, there are of course laws, legal systems, judicial systems, laws, basically a formal expression of society's agreement on basic principles by which we will conduct ourselves in relation to others. It is the way in which we express the ideals of our respective societies the greatness To the Western world of law from the Magna Carta in 2015, was the notion that no person including the sovereign is above the law, and that all persons should be secure from the arbitrary exercise of the powers of government. The Magna Carta is the legal ancestor of the concept of the rule of law. And with the breakup of the Soviet Union, we've had a sudden expansion of nation states, trying to establish democratic societies under the rule of law.

The rule of law and the ideals it enforces exist only in only a part of the world today. Since September the 11th, we've been reminded that other parts of the world do not share our notions of the rule of law, or the notion that it's the key to Liberty, but it seems to me that at every level Every nation state must have relations, commerce and dealings with other nations and with businesses in other nations. There is inevitably the need for the resolution of international disputes. And law will follow because the world community increasingly regards the shift away from cronyism and towards the rule of law as a prerequisite for doing business.

Now, the classic statement about how and why international law developed, was made some years ago by Lewis Hankin. It bears quoting. "Every nation derives some benefits from international law and international agreements. Law keeps International Society running, contributes to order and stability, provides a basis and a framework for common enterprise and mutual intercourse." Because it limits the actions of other governments, law enhances each nation's independence and security and other ways to by general law or particular agreement. One Nation gets others to behave as it desires. And just as we have said in this country since The Paquete Habana case, international law is part of our law.

International law, which is the expression of agreement on some basic principles of relations between nations will be a factor or a force
in gaining a greater consensus among all nations concerning some basic principles of their relations, one with one another. It can be and it is a help in our search for a more peaceful world. acting in accord with international norms may increase the chances for development of broader alliances. Or at least silence support from other nations. The efforts that Georgetown Law Center makes to educate law students from this country and abroad about international law. Our efforts well spent. programs such as this law school provides also important if the American legal profession is going to take seriously the realities of practice. Not only the ways in which transnational legal issues must be addressed, but also the potential for using the law to make a difference in the issues facing our world.

The need for lawyers in these difficult times has not decreased. It has increased because of the scope of the problems we face. Understanding international law is no longer just a legal specialty. It is becoming a duty And the continued efforts of academic specialists and international law are vital. If practitioners as well as judges are to faithfully discharge their duty international laws one of the few legal issues that can be resolved in part by expert testimony. Those expert witnesses are frequently scholars in international law. Judges and practitioners called upon to apply foreign law in choice of law cases often must rely on academic assessments of unfamiliar legal regimes. The trustworthiness and authority of those secondary sources is a vital importance to the administration of such cases in our courts, educational efforts that will improve and assure high quality briefs and materials submitted by litigants and by friends and the court will be with Welcome, indeed, congratulations to all of you to the Georgetown Law Center, to ambassador and Mrs. hotel for putting into operation, the Eric E Hotung international law building and its multiple programs. The location right here in our nation's capital, and so near the Congress and the federal courts is particularly helpful. You can be sure that you will contribute greatly to the enhancement of the rule of law throughout the world. And I look forward to many contacts with you in these areas in the years ahead. You will be a very good neighbor indeed. Thank you.